Dear Readers, Please Comment

We all love attention, admit it. That little rush you get when you see 20 comments on a single post sort of makes life feel ok again.

But that's not what this post is about. As much as I like shameless self-promotion, that's not what I'm looking for commments about.

savetheforums.gif

It's about my forums. Let's not dance around the issue like we're at a White House press conference, let's just say it. They're not pretty. In fact, they're barely usable. They're like tamagotchi's. They were hot in their prime but have since fizzled. Some of you may have even noticed the subtle disappearance of the recent topics on my sidebar. I couldn't take the daily reminder of how little they were visited or how poorly they functioned.

So I'm throwing the question out there for some feedback. Here are my options:

1. Kill my forums. Just take them out back and shoot them. They'll disappear from my menu bar forever.

2. Revamp my forums. As much as it pains me, I'd probably just take a vanilla template from the forum software and focus less on wowing people with my graphics and more on making them a place for connecting.

3. Start fresh. Setup forums at www.cardboardwhite.com

I've been leaning towards a mix of 1 and 3. I don't want to give up on forums altogether, especially with this growing community of friends. Try as I might, I can never really keep up as I'd like to. The closest I've come is by using Vienna to subscribe to everyone's RSS feed. But that doesn't let me know when people have responded to my comments, so often I miss out on great discussions and don't get inside jokes. Forums help faciliate discussion, which is really what our blogs are about anyhow.

Of course, there's the issue of identity and control. If you're posting at cardboardwhite.com, it's not on your site, and that might be a big deal for some--which is why I'm asking everyone to weigh in on this.

Thanks!

(I love exclamation points!!!)

  • posted on 21 November 2006
  • by Jesse

InterAction:

21 November 20061. jscottkill:

Personally, I have to admit that with the advent of such a large blogging community, I find it hard to keep up with forums anymore. Andy alluded on a recent post to the fact that blogs have become the new forums. Maybe your efforts would be better served in beefing up Cardboardwhite somehow.

21 November 20062. ren:

I don't realy have any constructive input at this time (I'm having a stressful morning), but I just wanted to congratulate you on your use of the tamagotchi reference. Nice!

21 November 20063. seriousandy:

Cardboardshite! Cardboardshite! What a great place to forumize!

21 November 20064. Jesse Gardner:

My web design business really centers around blogging, so I understand the boom. But the major disadvantage for blogs is keeping up with the discussion. Blogs are fitting for one person to make a statement and multiple people to comment on that statement, but unless comments have an RSS feed, interaction between commenters is less than ideal. It's terribly frustrating to resort to "@jscottkill: this reply is to you, blah blah blah" when forums are specifically crafted to keep everyone abreast of the developing conversation.

I've seen tight integration between a blog and forum, a forog of sorts, pulled off succesfully; but you run into the disadvantage of the topics discussed being controlled by one person. 'Tis a quandry, especially since I just want to help facilitate discussion and make keeping in touch with each other easier. Or is everyone satisfied with the way things work?

21 November 20065. Marlo:

I've been thinking the same as you for a while. From what I could tell (frustrating as that may be for you) no one was discussing on your forums.
A few times I've wondered if people have been discussing things somewhere and just not telling me about it. (I've got a weird complex or something.)
All that to say- maybe cardboardwhite or shite- is the way to go. Everyone's already used to it and adding a forum would be a great addition. And the #1 rule: we can do all the blog-pimping we want!

21 November 20066. Mike R:

Whoah! I know that the 's' and 'w' are near each other on my keyboard, but the meaning totally changes when a typo like this is re-read.

21 November 20067. Jesse Gardner:

Mike: Yeah... it's an inisde joke. (Inside meaning inside the twisted mind of Andy Martin!)

21 November 20068. seriousandy:

By the way, Jesse...

In regards to your frustration about the lack of ability to keep track of comments...how do trackbacks fit into the picture? What do you know about pingback comments and trackback comments? I've tried to figure them out on my blog and have failed. Do they, perhaps, hold the answer?

21 November 20069. LaRosa Johnson:

i really don't know. a problem i've faced for some time and have no answer to...

i think cardboardwhite is a great place to add the forum... and maybe one of these days i'll get my UrbanWordz blog together so that it can be added to the list

lj.

22 November 200610. angela:

what forums?

;)

22 November 200611. dave:

I'm going to miss the old forums.
Many a rainy afternoon was spent there.


YourThoughts?



(Minutia)

This entry was written by Jesse on Tuesday, November 21, 2006 at 12:50 AM and appears in the Blogging chapter. The previous article was entitled, "Verkeersbordvrij: Europe's Great Traffic Experiment", and the next entry is called, "Situational Ethics". Bookmark the permalink, save it to del.icio.us or Digg it.

GetUpdated

ElseWhere

Find me on aim Find me on delicious Find me on digg Find me on linkedin Find me on pownce Find me on twitter Find me on youtube Find me on skype Find me on facebook Find me on livejournal Find me on msn Find me on vox Find me on technorati Find me on yahoo Find me on dopplr

ActionStream

  • Jesse said, "@challies » Only if you have fun." Jesse said, “@challies » Only if you have fun.” 2008-08-27T18:59:09Z 2008-08-27T18:59:09Z
  • Jesse said, "@daveTHERIOcom » Yep, @ethanscott" Jesse said, “@daveTHERIOcom » Yep, @ethanscott” 2008-08-27T18:57:25Z 2008-08-27T18:57:25Z
  • Jesse said, "Just got a beautiful Excer-saucer for @ethanscott from @lilia_photo!" Jesse said, “Just got a beautiful Excer-saucer for @ethanscott from @lilia_photo!” 2008-08-27T16:10:15Z 2008-08-27T16:10:15Z
  • Jesse said, "Ok MT smarties, a question: Large blog network trying to set up system-level image asset fields so global templates work too. Possible? How?" Jesse said, “Ok MT smarties, a question: Large blog network trying to set up system-level image asset fields so global templates work too. Possible? How?” 2008-08-27T15:42:19Z 2008-08-27T15:42:19Z
  • Jesse said, "I'm tired. The past two nights Ethan has cried non-stop (literally) from 11pm until 3am despite being fed, burped, held or changed." Jesse said, “I’m tired. The past two nights Ethan has cried non-stop (literally) from 11pm until 3am despite being fed, burped, held or changed.” 2008-08-27T12:47:10Z 2008-08-27T12:47:10Z