Transparency: How Much Is Too Much?

How transparent is too transparent?

Well-meaning people tell me that honesty and transparency are key characteristics of any good leader. "It let's people know that you're human, helps them trust you more" one good friend said to me.

But would people want to know all of your struggles? What if you were a pastor and you had questions about the very core doctrines you taught? What if you were the CEO of a company built on a premise you don't buy? What if your pursuit of the truth caused you to break ranks with those not yet facing such struggles, or having perhaps come up with a different answer. At what point would "we love you" become "whoa, whoa, whoa..."?

Of course everyone is picturing the worst. He's gone off the deep end they'll say. Next up we'll see his picture on Drudge having microwaved his cat or strangled his wife. But before you cast the stone, please know that I am not about to jump ship. I have questions; not just "huh, that would be an interesting Trivial Pursuit question" questions, but "shake the whole foundation of your life" questions. Perhaps it's because I see the world as interconnected; every belief, every fact in some way manifesting itself in reality.

So when we argue about evolution versus creationism, I don't see monkeys versus dust, I see myself waking up tomorrow with purpose versus waking up tomorrow with none. When we argue about situational ethics, I don't see Jewish midwives versus Ten Commandments, I see myself lying to get ahead in my business versus being honest even if it costs me real money. When we argue about theism versus atheism, I don't see Lewis and Freud, I see a world in which I must dominate versus a world in which I must serve. Maybe it was my training as a writer. We were taught to connect the unknown to the known; it helps explain the unknown. But this is more than just coffee talk, it's my life.

That's probably why I like blogging. I have a chance to ask the questions that most people would swoon over were I to mention it in person. Fides quaerens intellectum is rarely welcome in churches these days. Matters of practice take up so much time that they seem to strangle any deeper discussion.

But at what point should my inner struggle become a matter of public discussion?

  • posted on 2 December 2006
  • by Jesse

InterAction:

4 December 20062. ren:

We just finished a book by Bill Hull called Choosing the Life.
I really have to recommend it. In it he discusses having an environment of grace and relationships of grace. By creating an environment of grace and relationships of grace we encourage transparency, and thus true honesty and trust. With true honesty and trust comes the ability to submit ourselves to one another. And in submission to each other we are able to grow and to help each other grow. We cannot encourage and strengthen each other in Christ if we are unaware of the questions and struggles there. How safe you feel sharing your inner struggles is up to you. Certainly it depends on with whom they are being shared. So, I suppose the transparency is depending on the trust. And the trust is dependent on the respect and the grace. In a relationship where no grace is offered, who is going to be transparent. There transparency means a beat-down. Where grace is present, transparency mean spiritual fellowship and nuturing. I don't know if that helps any, but it's what I though of when I read your post.

4 December 20063. Jesse Gardner:

Thanks for the link, Honour. I certainly smiled when I read it.

And your words, Ren, were particularly helpful to me. I suspect alot of what I wrote was borne out of frustration with certain people/situations. Food for thought to be sure!

4 December 20064. xpressionccr:

There is a line in the musical "Wicked" of which this idea reminds me:

"There are precious few at ease
With moral ambiguities.
So, We pretend they simply don't exist."

Have you read "Velvet Elvis" by Rob Bell. There is a section on questioning that I thing speaks beautifully to this. Go. Read it now! Quick. Quick.

4 December 20065. xpressionccr:

I thing? yeah...that's cool. I THINK!

4 December 20066. jscottkill:

I struggle with serious doubt all the time, because the hard truth ot the matter is, there is absolutely no way to establish absolute truth absolutely. I am not saying it doesn't exist; what I am saying is there is no way to know anything beyond the verifiability of the senses, which are fundamentally flawed. So, finding truth about problematic things, like say--the Doctrine of the Trinity or gay marriage, is very tough.

I find comfort not in absolute truth, but in probability. It is possible that the universe is a series of random firings and that life is merely a fortunate run of the numbers, but I find it more probable to beleive in purpose and a Driver of that Purpose. All things are possible, not all things are probable, and that's good enough for me--it has to be, or I'd find no way to be content with anything.

4 December 20067. jscottkill:

How would one get an MP3 of "Ill Fly Away" (your version)? I'm thinking of doing it as part of our worship at church.

4 December 20068. cmjackso:

I love what "ren" said. I was raised in an atmosphere where the leader was above everyone. The pastor or the couselor appeared to have it all together and therefore helped those of us below him who actually struggle. I don't think they intended that sort of pride, but it came across that way. I am more comfortable learning from and sharing with a leader who is humble and open. I think there are definitely boundaries, though. If you stay in the ministry, you will have to find your own balance.

5 December 20069. Dave:


I agree,
Although It is important that a leader be honest to his subjects, It is also important that he remain a strong example for those underneath him.


YourThoughts?



(Minutia)

This entry was written by Jesse on Saturday, December 2, 2006 at 10:29 PM and appears in the Mind chapter. The previous article was entitled, "Happy Birthday, Baby!", and the next entry is called, "My Power: Klutziness". Bookmark the permalink, save it to del.icio.us or Digg it.

GetUpdated

ElseWhere

Find me on aim Find me on delicious Find me on digg Find me on linkedin Find me on pownce Find me on twitter Find me on youtube Find me on skype Find me on facebook Find me on livejournal Find me on msn Find me on vox Find me on technorati Find me on yahoo Find me on dopplr

ActionStream

  • Jesse said, "Ethan slept from 8 to 12, 12:30 to 4:30 and 5:00 to now. Turns out he needed to eat more. I would really, really like to high five someone." Jesse said, “Ethan slept from 8 to 12, 12:30 to 4:30 and 5:00 to now. Turns out he needed to eat more. I would really, really like to high five someone.” 2008-08-28T12:36:25Z 2008-08-28T12:36:25Z
  • Jesse said, "By the way, if you're one of my clients, I'm not singling you out. Came home to five client emergencies tonight. :)" Jesse said, “By the way, if you’re one of my clients, I’m not singling you out. Came home to five client emergencies tonight. :)” 2008-08-28T03:34:13Z 2008-08-28T03:34:13Z
  • Jesse said, "@simplebits » Or taste. I'd love to lick some of your websites." Jesse said, “@simplebits » Or taste. I’d love to lick some of your websites.” 2008-08-28T02:16:28Z 2008-08-28T02:16:28Z
  • Jesse said, "@snookca » Yours too?" Jesse said, “@snookca » Yours too?” 2008-08-28T02:13:57Z 2008-08-28T02:13:57Z
  • Jesse said, "@rayners » Clients give me late night phone calls and $USD. Ethan gives me poopy diapers and kisses." Jesse said, “@rayners » Clients give me late night phone calls and $USD. Ethan gives me poopy diapers and kisses.” 2008-08-28T02:13:37Z 2008-08-28T02:13:37Z